Measure and comparison of economic, social and ecological sustainability of farming systems in the Marvdasht plain

Document Type: Research Paper

Authors

Faculty of Agricultural Economics and Development, University of Tehran, Karaj, Iran

Abstract

Agricultural sustainability refers to the ability of a cropping system to produce, without causing irreversible damage to
the ecosystem. There is an increasing need to view cropping systems and identify management practices in a holistic
indicator-based impact assessment. The main objective of this study was to compare and rank the cropping systems of the
Marvdasht plain in Fars Province; in order to show the gap between them. To achieve this aim, sustainability were divided
into four levels based on Composite Index(CI),which is useful for the identification of sustainability and includes three
dimension: (1) economical, (2) social, and (3) environmental and consist of 11 indicators. Required data were collected by
questionnaire from 200 cropping farmers who were selected through a stratified sampling design from six regions located
in Marvdasht plain. The computer software of SPSS was used to analyse the data. Indicators were normalized using the
division by means technique and were weighted. The weightings were derived from Principal Component Analysis
(PCA). CI was used to map the sustainability levels at the plain. According to classifying CI, four categories were
identified, which zone 6 identified as being unsustainable, while two zones 2 and 3 were considered as belonging to the
relatively unsustainable and the zone 5 was identified as relatively sustainable and the remaining zones (1,4) were
classified as sustainable. We conclude that the usage of multidimensional and holistic CI for analysing sustainability of
complex cropping systems is extremely important.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Abdollahzadeh, G., Kh. Kalantari, A. Asadi, R. Fisher, Zh.
Daneshvar Ameri, 2012. Spatial Patterns of Agricultural
Development: Application of the Composite Index
Approach. Journal of Agricultural Science and
Technology, 14; 51-64.
Ahuja, L.R., 2003. Quantifying agricultural management
effects on soil properties and processes. Journal of
Geoderma, 116; 1–2.
Anderson, R.L., 2005. Improving sustainability of cropping
systems in the central Great Plains. Journal of
sustainable Agriculture, 26; 97-114.
Andreoli, M., V. Tellarini, 2000. Farm sustainability
evaluation: Methodology and practice. Journal of
Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 77; 43-52.
Bosshard, A., 2000. A methodology and terminology of
sustainability assessment and its perspectives for
rural planning . Journal of Agriculture, Ecosystems and
Environment, 77; 29-41.
Comer, S., E. Ekanem, S. Muhammad, S. Singh, F.
Tegegne, 1999. Sustainable and conventional farmers:
A comparison of socioeconomic characteristics,
attitude, and beliefs. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture,
15; 1.
Darvishi, A.K., 2003. Capacity and Ability of Sustainable
Development in Iran. Iranian Journal of Agricultural
and Ecologic Development, 5; 30-53.
Dumanski, J., C. Pieri, 2000. Land quality indicators:
research plan. Agriculture, Journal of Ecosystems and
Environment, 81; 93–102.
Gafsi, M., B. Legagneux, G. Nguyen, P. Robin, 2006.
Towards sustainable farming systems: Effectiveness
and deficiency of the French procedure of sustainable
agriculture. Journal of Agricultural Systems, 90; 226–
242.
Gahinl, A., 1998. The Search for Useful Indicators:
Attempts to Measure Agricultural Sustainability.
Journal of Environment, 38; 15–31.
Girardin, P., C. Bockstaller., H. Van der Werf, 1999.
Indicators: Tools to Evaluate the Environmental
Impacts of Farming Systems. Journal of Sustainabale
and Agriculture, 13; 5–21.
Guy, S.M., D.L, Rogers, 1999. Community surveys:
Measuring citizens’ attitudes toward sustainability.
Journal of Extension, 37; 3.
Hayati, D., 1995. Factors influencing technical knowledge,
Sustainable agriculture knowledge and sustainability of
farming system among wheat producers in Fars
province. M.Sc. thesis, agricultural extension and
education, University of Shiraz, Iran.
Herzog, F., N. Gotsch, 1998. Assessing the sustainability
of smallholder tree crop production in the tropics: A
methodological outline. Journal of Sustainable
Agriculture, 11; 4.
Ingels, C., D. Campbell, M.R. George, E. Bradford, 1997.
What is sustainable agriculture? Available from
http://www.sarep.ucdavis.edu/concept.htm.
Karami, E., K. Rezaei Moghaddam, 1998. Poverty and
Sustainable Agriculture: A Qualitative Analysis. Iranian
Quarterly Journal of Rural Development Studies, 2; 1-
29.
Karami, E., 1995. Agricultural Extension: Question of
sustainable development in Iran. Journal of Sustainable
Agriculture, 5; 1-2.
Karbasioun, M., M. Mulder., H. Biemans, 2008. Changes
and Problems of Agricultural Development in Iran.
World Journal of Agricultural Science, 4; 759-769.
Kalantari, Kh., 2001. Regional Development Planning;
Theories And Techniques, Khoshbin Publications,
Tehran, Iran, P; 290.
Koeijer, D., A. Wossink, C. Struik, A. Renkema, 2002.
Measuring agricultural sustainability in terms of
efficiency: the case of Dutch sugar beet growers.
Journal of Environmental Management, 66; 9-17.
Krajnc, D., P. Glavic, 2005. How to Compare Companies
on Relevant Dimensions of Sustainability. Journal of
Ecological and Economic, 55; 551– 563.
Lyson, T.A., 1998. Environmental, economic and social
aspects of sustainable agriculture in American Land
Grant Universities. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture,
12; 2-3.
Meadows, D.H., 1994. The Limits to Growth: A Report for
the Club of Rome’s Project on the Predicament of
Mankind. New York, Report number: 1, PP; 33-42.
Mohammadi, H., 2009. Investigation of water productivity
in Marvdasht. Journal of Agricultural Economics, PP;
25-37.
Ogaji, J., 2005. Sustainable agriculture in the UK.
Environment, Journal of Development and
Sustainability, 7; 253–270.
Pacini, C., A. Wossink, G. Giesen, C. Vazzana, R. Huirne,
2004. Evaluation of sustainability of organic, integrated
and conventional farming systems: a farm and fieldscale
analysis. Journal of Agriculture, Ecosystems and
Environment, 92; 273–288.
Pannell, D.J., S. Schilizzi, 1999. Sustainable agriculture: a
question of ecology, ethics, economic efficiency or 

expedience? Journal of Sustainable Agriculture, 13; 57–
66.
Pannell, D.J., N.A. Glenn, 2000. Frame work for the
economic evaluation and selection of sustainability
indicators in agriculture. Journal of Ecological
Economics, 33; 135–149.
Passel, S.V., F. Nevens, E. Mathijs, G.V. Huylenbroeck,
2006. Measuring farm sustainability and explaining
differences in sustainable efficiency. Journal of
Ecological Economics, 3; 135-138.
Rasul, G., G.B. Thapa, 2003. Sustainability Analysis of
Ecological and Conventional Agricultural Systems in
Bangladesh. Journal of World Development, 31; 1721–
1741.
Rezaei Moghaddam, K., E. Karami, J. Gibson, 2005.
Conceptualizing Sustainable Agriculture: Iran as an
illustrative Case. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture,
27; 25-56.
Rezaie Moghaddam, K., 1997. Poverty and sustainable
agriculture in Behbahan County. M.Sc. thesis,
Agricultural extension and education, University of
Shiraz, Iran.
Roseland, M., 1998. Toward Sustainable Communities:
Resources for Citizens and Their Governments. New
Society Publishers, Gabriola Island, PP; 256.
Saltiel, J., J.W. Baunder, S. Palakovich, 1994. Adoption of
sustainable agricultural practices: diffusion farm
structure and profitability. Journal of Rural Sociology,
59; 333-347.
Shahvali, M., 2008. Investigation of sustainable patterns in
Marvdasht. Iran Journal of Agricultural, 1; 39.
Veleva. V., M. Ellenbecker, 2000. A Proposal for
Measuring Business Sustainability: Addressing
Shortcomings in Existing Frameworks. Journal of
Greener Management, 31; 101–120.
Wei, Y.P., R.E. White, D. Chen, B. Davidson, J.B. Zhang,
2007. Farmers’ perception of sustainability indicators
for crop production on the North China Plain. Journal of
Sustainable Agriculture, 30; 129–147.
Xu, X., L. Hou, H. Lin, W. Liu, 2004. Zoning of
Sustainable Agricultural Development in China. Journal
of Agricultural Systems, 87; 38–62.